Skip to main content

Institutions and regulation

The FCA Signals a Shift on Crypto: How to Read a Regulator

The UK's FCA published a speech on changing its crypto approach. Here is how financial regulation actually gets made, and what it changes for users.

7 min read19 November 2026CryptoBipto editorial

The FCA Signals a Shift on Crypto: How to Read a Regulator

The UK's Financial Conduct Authority has published a speech titled "The courage to change," setting out how the regulator's approach to crypto is evolving. The text is on the FCA's own website, fca.org.uk, alongside the hundreds of other speeches, consultations and policy statements the organisation puts out every year.

A speech is not a rule. Nothing in it changes what is legal in Britain on the day it is delivered. And yet people who work in regulated finance read these documents carefully, because a speech is often the earliest public signal of where the rules are heading, sometimes a year or two before anything binding appears.

That gap — between a regulator talking and a regulator writing rules — is the thing worth understanding. It outlasts any single headline. If you learn how a financial regulator actually moves, you can read the next ten announcements yourself instead of relying on someone else's summary.

Our news summary of the speech is here.

First, who the FCA is

The Financial Conduct Authority is the United Kingdom's main conduct regulator for financial services. "Conduct" means how firms behave towards customers and markets: whether they tell the truth in advertising, whether they handle your money properly, whether they have systems to catch fraud.

It is roughly the British counterpart to the Securities and Exchange Commission in the United States, though the comparison is loose. The FCA covers a wider slice of consumer finance — banks' retail conduct, insurance, consumer credit — and it writes much of its own rulebook rather than mainly enforcing statutes written by legislators.

The FCA does not decide what is a security or a commodity in the way American agencies argue about. Its starting question is different: is this activity inside the regulatory perimeter?

The perimeter is the whole game

The regulatory perimeter is the legal boundary around activities that require permission from the regulator. Inside it, you must be authorised, you must follow the rulebook, and your customers get certain protections. Outside it, you are free to operate — and your customers are largely on their own.

This is the single most useful concept for understanding crypto rules in any country, not just Britain. Most arguments about "regulating crypto" are really arguments about where to draw that line.

For a general grounding in how these frameworks differ country to country, see our glossary entry on crypto regulation.

In the UK, crypto has historically sat in an awkward position: partly inside the perimeter, mostly outside it. Here is roughly how the layers stacked up.

LayerWhat it coversWhat it does not cover
Anti-money-laundering registrationFirms doing crypto exchange or custody in the UK must register with the FCA and run identity and monitoring checksWhether the firm is solvent, honest with pricing, or safe to use
Financial promotions rulesHow crypto can be advertised and marketed to UK consumers, including risk warnings and cooling-off periods for new customersThe product itself
Retail product restrictionsA ban, which took effect in January 2021, on selling crypto derivatives and crypto exchange-traded notes to retail consumers; the FCA has since revisited parts of thisDirect buying of crypto assets

Notice the pattern. Each layer regulates something around crypto — the money-laundering risk, the advertising, a packaged financial product — rather than crypto trading itself. That is the perimeter problem in one table.

Registration is not authorisation

This distinction trips up a lot of people, and it is worth slowing down for.

Registration under the money-laundering rules means a firm has satisfied the regulator that it has adequate controls against financial crime. That is it. The FCA checks the firm's anti-money-laundering systems and the fitness of its senior people.

Authorisation is a much bigger thing. An authorised firm has permission to carry on specific regulated activities, must hold capital, must follow conduct rules, and its customers may have access to complaint and compensation schemes.

A crypto firm that is registered but not authorised is not a "regulated crypto exchange" in the way most people imagine. The register tells you the firm passed a crime-prevention check. It does not tell you your money is protected if the firm fails.

The FCA says this itself, repeatedly, in plain language on fca.org.uk. People still miss it, partly because firms enjoy the ambiguity of the word "regulated" in their marketing.

If you only take one thing from this post: find out which permission a firm actually holds, and what that permission covers. "Registered with the FCA" and "your funds are protected" are different sentences.

How a rule is actually born

Regulators in the UK, the EU and most comparable jurisdictions move through a recognisable sequence. Learning it lets you place any news story on a timeline.

  1. Speeches and "Dear CEO" letters. Soft signals. No legal force. Industry reads them for direction.
  2. Discussion paper. The regulator poses open questions: should we do something here, and if so, what are the trade-offs?
  3. Consultation paper. A draft of proposed rules, with a deadline for written responses from firms, consumer groups and the public. Anyone can respond.
  4. Policy statement. The regulator publishes final rules, usually with a summary of the feedback it received and what it changed in response.
  5. Handbook amendment and implementation date. The rules enter the rulebook, often with a transition period of months or years.

A speech sits at step one. That is why "regulator signals shift" headlines so rarely come with anything you need to do that week. It is also why they matter: by step four, the shape of the rules is largely settled, and the window to influence them has closed.

Also worth knowing: the FCA writes rules, but Parliament and the Treasury decide what the FCA is allowed to write rules about. Expanding the perimeter to cover crypto trading and custody properly requires legislation first, then FCA rulemaking second. Two bodies, two timelines.

The MiCA comparison

The European Union took a different route. Rather than extending existing categories piece by piece, it wrote a dedicated rulebook: the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation, known as MiCA.

MiCA's defining feature is passporting. A firm authorised in one member state can serve customers across the whole bloc without applying separately in each country, provided it meets common rules on reserves, disclosures and customer protection. It is comparable to a driving licence recognised everywhere in the union.

The UK is no longer in the EU, so MiCA does not apply there. Britain has been building its own regime, and the practical question the FCA keeps circling is whether a UK framework ends up stricter, looser, or simply differently shaped than MiCA. For a firm deciding where to set up, that comparison is the business case.

Stablecoins are where the two approaches collide most visibly, because a stablecoin is simultaneously a payment instrument, a claim on a reserve, and a trading asset. Our lesson on the risks, regulation and use cases of stablecoins walks through why reserve rules and redemption rights are the parts that actually determine whether a token holds its peg under stress.

The tension the FCA is managing

The British government has said publicly it wants the UK to be an attractive base for crypto and blockchain firms. The FCA's statutory objectives include protecting consumers and promoting market integrity, and it has a secondary objective relating to international competitiveness and growth.

Those pull in different directions. A regulator that admits very few firms protects consumers from bad firms and also from good ones. A regulator that admits many firms grows the sector and inherits its failures. There is no setting that avoids the trade-off; there are only different places to sit on it.

"The courage to change" is, read charitably, an acknowledgement that the FCA's earlier position — cautious, warning-heavy, slow to approve registrations — was calibrated for a different moment and may need recalibrating. Read sceptically, it is a regulator under political pressure explaining why it is loosening. Both readings are available from the same document, which is normal for speeches.

The same tension shows up at the privacy end of the spectrum, where anti-money-laundering obligations meet tools designed to resist surveillance. Our lesson on privacy versus regulation covers the Travel Rule and why identity requirements on transfers are so contested.

What this changes for you

Nothing immediately, if you are a user. But here is what is worth checking in any jurisdiction, not just the UK.

  • What permission does the firm hold, and from whom? Regulators publish searchable registers. Look the firm up directly rather than trusting a badge on a website.
  • Does the permission cover the specific service you use? A firm might be authorised for payments and unregulated for crypto trading, in the same app.
  • What happens if the firm fails? Compensation schemes and ombudsman services generally do not cover unregulated crypto activity. Find out before you need the answer.
  • Are you a customer of the entity you think you are? Large groups operate many legal entities across many countries. The one holding your account may not be the one named in the press release.

Rules change. The habit of checking does not go out of date.

Source: the speech discussed here was published by the Financial Conduct Authority on fca.org.uk. This post is educational and is not financial, legal or investment advice.

CryptoBipto

Start at the level that suits you and learn at your own pace.